The Best Smart Scales To Track Weight, BMI, Body Fat Percentage And More (2024)

Jump To:

  • Quick List
  • The Best Smart Scales
  • Best Overall
  • Best Budget Smart Scale
  • Best For Apple Health
  • Best For Garmin Users
  • Best For Xiaomi Users
  • Best For Using Without An App
  • Best Smart Scale For MyZone Users
  • More Great Smart Scales
  • Buying Advice

Best Smart Scales: Jump Menu

The Best Smart Scales To Track Weight, BMI, Body Fat Percentage And More (1)

The Quick List↴
1. Best Overall: Withings Body Smart
2. Best Budget Smart Scale: Renpho Smart Body Fat
3. Best Smart Scale For Apple Health: Wyze Scale X
4. Best Smart Scale For Garmin Users: Garmin Index S2
5. Best Smart Scale For Xiaomi Users: Xiaomi Mi Body Composition 2
6. Best For Use Without An App: Tanita BC-731
7. Best Smart Scale For MyZone Users: MyZone MZ-20
Buying Advice

There was a time when choosing a set of bathroom scales was straightforward. Scales displayed your weight, and other than that it was mostly an aesthetic choice. The smart scales you can buy now, however, go beyond basic weight measurements and can be a useful health-tracking tool, even if you’re not aiming to lose weight.

Many of these modern marvels can measure body fat and tell you how much of your body is muscle, water and bone. Some can even check your heart health. Many scales will recognise which member of your household is stepping on the scale and send your results to an app.

Keeping an eye on those stats can be useful in a number of scenarios beyond knowing if your weight is trending up over time. And, indeed, down, as rapid weight loss can be a sign of illness or that you’re under-fuelling (when we interviewed Ali Nolan about women and marathon training, she mentioned that women often don’t consume enough calories to support their training). Knowing if you have a healthy body fat percentage can also help you from falling foul of the problems with BMI.

When deciding on a smart scale, it’s worth factoring in whether you own, or plan to buy, a fitness tracker. Many major tracker manufacturers make smart scales and combining your health data into one app is more convenient. With the limitations of Fitbit’s current scale offering, you may wish to shop for another of our best fitness trackers.

You may like

  • Renpho Smart Body Fat Scale Review
  • Withings Body Smart Scale Review

The Quick List

These are my top picks for smart scales in various categories and why I rate them so highly. Click on the links to jump to the full reviews further down the page.

Best overall

1. Withings Body Smart

Best Overall

This is a high-quality Wi-Fi-connected smart scale at a reasonable price and it has all the body composition metrics you could want. The weigh-in process is quick and easy—there’s no need to have your phone to hand—and the app is user-friendly.

Read more below

Best budget smart scale

2. Renpho Smart Body Fat

Best Budget Smart Scale

A small, Bluetooth-connected smart scale that’s great value at list price and is often reduced on Amazon. It covers all the body composition metrics you could want and has an insightful and well-designed app.

Read more below

Best smart scale for Apple Health

3. Wyze Scale X

Best Smart Scale For Apple Health

This good-looking Bluetooth-connected scale shares data with Apple Health, Fitbit and Google. With modes for baby, pet and luggage, plus pregnancy and athlete modes, it’s versatile. It’s great value for those in the US, not so much for those in the UK.

Read more below

Best smart scale for Garmin users

4. Garmin Index S2

Best Smart Scale For Garmin Users

The smart scale to buy if you want your data seamlessly integrated into Garmin Connect. It’s on the expensive side, but does everything you’d expect.

Read more below

Best smart scale for Xiaomi users

5. Xiaomi Mi Body Composition Scale 2

Best Smart Scale For Xiaomi Users

If you have a Xiaomi device, such as a Mi Band, this scale is the obvious choice. It will integrate your body composition data into the app, offering a blunt-but-astute analysis of the results.

Read more below

Best for using without an app

6. Tanita BC-731

Best For Using Without An App

This smart scale can be used with or without an app—buttons on the scale allow you to input your details directly into the machine. Its small footprint makes it suitable for those with a lack of space but less suitable for those with larger feet.

Read more below

Best Smart Scale For MyZone Users

7. MyZone MZ-20

Best Smart Scale For MyZone Users

A good-looking, well-priced Bluetooth-connected scale that’s handy for those with a MyZone heart rate monitor, slotting your body composition data in with your MEPs. Weighing in requires a process to be followed in the app though, and data is presented without context. Non MyZone users should look elsewhere.

Read more below

How I Test Smart Scales

You can trust Coach We give honest reviews and recommendations based on in-depth knowledge and real-world experience. Find out more about how we review and recommend products.

I’ve tested smart scales from brands including Withings, Garmin and Fitbit (the big names), as well as budget ones from Renpho and Xiaomi. During testing, I use each scale regularly for a period of several weeks or months, checking for accuracy and consistency, speed and ease of use, how useful any accompanying app is, and I compare it with other scales. I also look for, and test out, any special features that make the scale stand out from the competition. You’ll find links to full reviews for each of the smart scales I’ve tested.

The Best Smart Scales

Best Overall

The Best Smart Scales To Track Weight, BMI, Body Fat Percentage And More (9)

1. Withings Body Smart

Best all-rounder

Specifications

RRP: $99.95 / £89.95

Measurements given: Weight, body fat percentage, muscle mass, bone mass, lean mass, water percentage, visceral fat, heart rate, pulse wave velocity (basal metabolic rate and metabolic age will be added soon)

Connectivity: Connects via Wi-Fi to Withings app, compatible with Apple and Google health apps

Reasons to buy

+

Wi-Fi connection

+

Smart-looking

+

Easy to set up

+

Good value

Reasons to avoid

-

App less motivating than others

-

Not the cheapest

The Body Smart is the most affordable of the three smart scales in high-end health tech brand Withings’ current line-up, and it provides all the body composition metrics you could want, without too many gimmicks.

The Body Smart looks the part, with a sharp color display and a sleek tempered-glass surface, available in either black or white. I found the weigh-in process quick and easy. The scale is Wi-Fi connected, so there was no need to have my phone to hand with the app open—next time I opened the app my data appeared, without fault.

I found the scale consistent and accurate, and the app easy to use. There was a good deal of information in the app about each type of metric and how to improve your lifestyle and therefore your score, yet I found the graphs lacking in context—in terms of how my data stacked up against others my age, sex and height. It was therefore less motivating than other apps, such as Renpho’s.

Withings has a range of excellent fitness trackers and smartwatches, including the ScanWatch and other devices like home blood pressure monitors. Even if you’re not tempted by any of those, it’s still worth checking out since the Withings app will share its data with Apple Watch and Apple Health, and Google Fit.

Read more in my Withings Body Smart review

Best Budget Smart Scale

The Best Smart Scales To Track Weight, BMI, Body Fat Percentage And More (10)

2. Renpho Smart Body Fat Scale

Best value smart scale

Specifications

RRP: $34.99 / £30.99

Measurements given: Weight, BMI, body fat, water, skeletal muscle, muscle mass, bone mass, protein, basal metabolic rate, subcutaneous fat, visceral fat, metabolic age

Connectivity: Connects via Bluetooth to Renpho app, compatible with Apple, Samsung, Fitbit and Google health apps

Reasons to buy

+

Affordable

+

Plenty of metrics

+

Easy to set up

+

Simple, intuitive app

Reasons to avoid

-

Scale only displays weight – app needed for other metrics

-

App needs to be open at weigh-in

Why fork out three figures for a smart scale when there’s a reliable and insightful set for a fraction of the price? I liked the Renpho scale for the extensive range of metrics it tracks, as well as its ease of use. Only weight is displayed on the scale, but the app does a great job of presenting data on the 13 metrics it offers, from body fat and visceral fat (the dangerous fat around your organs), to your basal metabolic rate and metabolic age.

There’s plenty of context to help you understand your data, such as color-coded results that show at a glance whether you’re in a healthy range. You need to have the app open in order for a weigh-in to register, but for more money you can invest in the Wi-Fi connected version, which will sync automatically every time you step on the plate. This scale is smaller than most, so could be a good choice if space is at a premium in your bathroom, but isn’t ideal if you have large feet.

Read more in my Renpho scale review

Best Smart Scale For Apple Health

The Best Smart Scales To Track Weight, BMI, Body Fat Percentage And More (11)

3. Wyze Scale X

Versatile household scale that’s good value in the US

Specifications

RRP: $33.99

Measurements given: Weight, BMI, body fat, water, muscle mass, bone mass, protein, basal metabolic rate, visceral fat, metabolic age, heart rate, lean body mass

Connectivity: Connects via Bluetooth to Wyze app, compatible with Apple, Fitbit and Google health apps

Reasons to buy

+

Smooth weigh-in process

+

No need to have the app open at weigh-in

+

Great value in the US

Reasons to avoid

-

App features lack analysis

-

Expensive in the UK

This good-looking smart scale can recognise up to eight users and plays nicely with other apps including Apple Health, Google Fit and Fitbit. It measures the most common body composition metrics, which the app then uses to calculate other stats, such as BMI, basal metabolic rate and metabolic age. It also has baby, pet, luggage and pregnancy modes.

Wyze includes heart rate measurements as one of the body metrics measured. This bypasses the scale, and the app instructs you to place your finger over the camera on your phone to obtain a measurement. The app shows weight trend graphs, gives context so you can understand the stats shown, and highlights progress made towards your chosen goals. The weigh-in process is smooth and you don’t need to have the app open while stepping on the scale—I found the scale reliably recorded my data and synced automatically when I next opened the app.

The app is easy to use but lacking in analysis and context, and I found it less motivating than other smart scale apps, such as Renpho and Withings apps. While it represents excellent value in the US at $33.99, the scale is not sold directly in the UK. It’s available from some third-party sellers, but at around £80 on Amazon UK it’s well out of the budget category and you’ll get better value from other scales.

Read more in my Wyze Scale X review

Best Smart Scale For Garmin Users

The Best Smart Scales To Track Weight, BMI, Body Fat Percentage And More (12)

4. Garmin Index S2 Smart Scale

Convenient body composition tracking for owners of Garmin wearables

Specifications

RRP: $149.99 / £129.99

Measurements given: Weight, BMI, body fat percentage, skeletal muscle mass, bone mass, body water percentage

Connectivity: Connects via WiFi to Garmin app and devices

Reasons to buy

+

Measures body composition stats and BMI

+

Complements information collected from Garmin’s wearables

+

Recognises up to 16 users

+

Customisable display

+

Automatically updates the app over WiFi

Reasons to avoid

-

Expensive

-

Falls short on data analysis

If you own a Garmin fitness tracker, this sleek-looking scale made with tempered glass offers convenience. It will slot your weight and body composition data in with your sleep and activity tracking in the Garmin app. The bright, clear display on the scale shows the most important body composition stats (plus, oddly, the weather) and the Wi-Fi connection means there’s no need to have the app open to log your weigh-in.

I found the app didn’t provide as much context for the body composition data as I’d have liked, such as what is considered a healthy range for your age group. If you’re not a Garmin user there are better-value options for you on this list.

Read more in my Garmin Index S2 Smart Scale review

Best Smart Scale For Xiaomi Users

The Best Smart Scales To Track Weight, BMI, Body Fat Percentage And More (13)

5. Xiaomi Mi Body Composition Scale 2

An affordable scale with a useful app

Specifications

RRP: $39.99 / £29.99

Measurements given: Weight, body fat, water, muscle, bone mass, protein, visceral fat, basal metabolic rate, metabolic age, BMI, ideal weight and body type

Connectivity: Connects via Bluetooth to Zepp Life app, compatible with Apple, Samsung and Google health apps

Reasons to buy

+

Easy integration for Xiaomi users

+

Body score offers useful overview

+

Offers effective advice

Reasons to avoid

-

Full weigh-in takes longer than other smart scales

-

Issues zeroing scale

-

Bluetooth connection requires app to be open

If you’ve already got a Xiaomi device, maybe it’s time to add this budget smart scale that will work effortlessly with the same app. It provides all the usual body composition metrics and can even test your balance. As you might expect, the affordable price means there are drawbacks: I found the scale slow to perform a full weigh-in, and if you move it between uses then it needs a nudge to get it to zero properly. That said, I found it reasonably accurate and consistent, and the data it collects is presented in the app in a useful and insightful (if somewhat blunt) manner. You’re given a body score, and any of your metrics that need attention are listed first, with tips on how to improve your results.

Read more in my Xiaomi Mi Body Composition Scale 2 review

Best For Using Without An App

The Best Smart Scales To Track Weight, BMI, Body Fat Percentage And More (14)

6. Tanita BC-731

Small smart scale that can be used with or without an app

Specifications

RRP: £72

Measurements given: Weight, body fat percentage, muscle mass, visceral fat, total body water, basal metabolic rate, metabolic age, physique rating, bone mass, BMI

Connectivity: Connects via Bluetooth to the MyTanita app, compatible with Apple Health and Google Fit

Reasons to buy

+

Can be used without app

+

Small footprint

Reasons to avoid

-

Uncomfortable for larger feet

-

Fiddly weigh-in process

-

Not the best-looking

This scale from the Japanese smart scale specialist Tanita measures all the important body composition metrics and can be used with or without the accompanying app. It stores data for up to five people and has an easy-to-use app that plots your data on graphs for an at-a-glance overview.

The weigh-in process is more fiddly than it needs to be, requiring buttons to be tapped on the app. It’s not the sleekest or most modern-looking scale either, but it takes up less space than most. The platform is only 8in (20cm) deep, so unless you have tiny feet your toes are likely to hang over the edge. Tanita says this doesn’t affect measurements, but you may find it uncomfortable to use.

Read more in my Tanita BC-731 review

Best Smart Scale For MyZone Users

The Best Smart Scales To Track Weight, BMI, Body Fat Percentage And More (15)

7. Myzone MZ-20 Home Scale

Best for MyZone users

Specifications

RRP: $50 / £59.99

Measurements given: Weight, BMI, body fat percentage, muscle mass percentage, basal metabolic rate, heart rate

Connectivity: Connects via Bluetooth to MyZone app

Reasons to buy

+

Easy integration for MyZone users

Reasons to avoid

-

Fiddly weigh-in process

-

Not many body composition metrics

Known for its heart rate monitors and heart rate tracking system that’s used in many gyms, MyZone also sells a Bluetooth-connected smart scale. The scale is reasonably priced yet looks great, with its sleek glass platform, and it’s available in black or white. Unfortunately, the glass isn’t tempered or toughened, as I found out when the edge chipped and splintered when I bumped it while moving it around my bathroom.

In order to register a weigh-in with the Myzone MZ-20 it’s not enough to have the app open and your phone nearby, you need to navigate within the app to the “me” page, and tap the scale icon at the bottom of the page, then tap continue, before the scale is ready to register your data.

Weight readings seemed accurate compared with other scales. The scale really only gives you two body composition metrics—body fat and muscle mass percentage—the results of which were comparable with other smart scales. The scale has a stab at calculating your basal metabolic rate, and it also records your heart rate, which it calls your resting heart rate (though I wouldn’t say I’m “at rest” when standing on a scale). There are a few body composition metrics I wish were included—bone mass and visceral fat, for starters. Data is tracked with graphs in the app but there’s no context to help you work out if you’re in a healthy range for your age and sex.

This scale could be a useful addition for dedicated MyZone users, but others would do better to look elsewhere, like Withings, Renpho or Wyze’s offerings.

More Great Smart Scales

The Best Smart Scales To Track Weight, BMI, Body Fat Percentage And More (16)

Fitbit Aria Air

Connected scale that tracks weight and BMI

Specifications

RRP: $49.95 / £49.99

Measurements given: Weight, BMI (through app)

Connectivity: Connects via Bluetooth to Fitbit app and devices

Reasons to buy

+

Multi-user weight tracking

+

Calculates BMI through the app

+

Cheaper than most smart scales

+

Connects via Bluetooth to Fitbit app

Reasons to avoid

-

Doesn’t offer body composition stats

-

Can have issues zeroing

If you’re a Fitbit user and you’re not interested in knowing your body fat percentage, consider this good-looking scale that does away with extra metrics for a simpler experience. It’ll measure your weight and send it to the Fitbit app via Bluetooth, where your BMI will be calculated and graphed. When I tested the Aria Air, I found the scale needed help to ensure it was properly zeroed after moving it, but was otherwise accurate.

Read more in my Fitbit Aria Air review

Buying Advice

Are smart scales worth it?

Top-end smart scales aren’t cheap and it’s worth investigating whether you need all that extra smart data. No one really needs to know their body’s protein content, do they? However, smart scales can be a useful tool to help you get a clearer picture of your overall health. Metrics like visceral fat (the dangerous fat that builds up around your organs) and bone mass can alert you to hidden issues or weaknesses, which surely makes smart scales worth the investment.

While readings can vary between scales and there can be accuracy issues, smart scales allow you to see trends over time. Budget smart scales do the same as more expensive ones, though you may find the weighing-in process is slower and they are more prone to connection problems.

Which is the best smart scale for athletes?

Many smart scales have an athlete mode usually aimed at people who do more than 10 hours of exercise a week and have a resting heart rate (RHR) that’s lower than 60. This setting tells the scale to give higher muscle and lower body fat readings. Scales I recommend that have athlete modes include: Withings Body Smart, Garmin Index S2, Wyze Scale X, Renpho Smart Body Fat Scale.

Many athletes want to use a scale that integrates their data into whatever app they use to track their activities. So, a Garmin user may find the Garmin Index S2 the best option, for example.

Are smart scales safe to use in pregnancy?

Most smart scales carry a warning that they are not safe for use during pregnancy. Smart scales use bioelectrical impedance analysis (BIA), sending a tiny electrical current through the body, and it’s not known if this could cause harm during pregnancy, so it’s best to be on the safe side. Many smart scales have a pregnancy mode, which just turns off the BIA and records weight only.

Get the Coach Newsletter

Sign up for workout ideas, training advice, reviews of the latest gear and more.

The Best Smart Scales To Track Weight, BMI, Body Fat Percentage And More (17)

Camilla Artault

Content editor

Camilla Artault is a writer and keen runner. She has covered women’s running gear – testing leggings, jackets, running bras, tops and shorts – forCoach since 2018, as well as interviewing experts and writing about a range of health and lifestyle topics.

With contributions from

  • Nick Harris-FrySenior writer

More about gear

Under Armour Reign 6 ReviewHow To Pace The Boston Marathon To Perfection With Garmin’s PacePro Tool

Latest

What Is The Difference Between Whey Concentrate And Whey Isolate?
See more latest►
The Best Smart Scales To Track Weight, BMI, Body Fat Percentage And More (2024)

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Otha Schamberger

Last Updated:

Views: 6229

Rating: 4.4 / 5 (55 voted)

Reviews: 86% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Otha Schamberger

Birthday: 1999-08-15

Address: Suite 490 606 Hammes Ferry, Carterhaven, IL 62290

Phone: +8557035444877

Job: Forward IT Agent

Hobby: Fishing, Flying, Jewelry making, Digital arts, Sand art, Parkour, tabletop games

Introduction: My name is Otha Schamberger, I am a vast, good, healthy, cheerful, energetic, gorgeous, magnificent person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.